[Douthett and Steinbach’s “Cube Dance” as reinterpreted by Dmitri Tymoczko] (http://www.mtosmt.org/issues/mto.10.16.1/mto.10.16.1.tymoczko.html):
See also machine listening, Arpeggiate by Numbers, clustering, manifold learning
Features, descriptors, metrics, kernels and affinities and the spaces and topologies they induce and what they reveal about composition. This has considerable overlap with machine listening, but there I start from audio signals, and here I usually think about more “symbolic” data such as musical scores, and with rhythm, but there I care only about the time axis. There is overlap also with psychoacoustic units, which are the pure elements from which these amalgams are made.
This is a specialized area with many fine careers built on it, and many schools with long and proud histories of calling adherents of other schools wrong. A short literature search will find many worth distinctions drawn between differences, cultural versus the biological, general versus individual, the different models applicable at different time scales, of masking effects and such.
I will largely pass over these fine contrasts here, in my quest for some pragmatically useful, minimally complex features for using in machine-learning algorithms, which do not require truth but functionality.
General musically-motivated metric spaces
Consider grouping chords played on a piano with some known (idealised) 16-harmonic spectrum. How can we understand the harmonic relations of chords played upon this keyboard?
We know a-priori that this projection can be naturally embedded in a Euclidean space with something less than dimensions, since there are at most that many spectral bands. In fact, since there are only 12 notes, we can get this down to 12 dimensions. The question is, can we get to an even smaller number of dimensions? How small? By “small” here, I mean, can I group chords on a lower number of dimensions than this in some musically interesting way? For bonus points, can I group chords into several different such maps and switch between them?
Without explanation, here is one similarity-distance embedding of all the chords using an ad hoc metric based on thinking about this question. (Brightness: The more notes in the chord, the darker. Hue: I forget.)
Question: can we use word-bag models for note adjacency representation? Since I asked that question I discovered the Chord2vec model of Walder's lab, whose answer is “yes”. See MaQW16.
Basic group theory: What are the symmetries of the group of all pitch class co-occurrences in the 12-tet? The most common pitch class co-occurrence is a 12-vector over the Boolean algebra where a “1” in the first entry means “the note C was played”, in pos 2, “C-sharp was played” etc Symmetries we care about are, for example, that (under equal temperament) chord harmonic relationships should be invariant under transposition - i.e. rotation of the entries of the vector. (this last is not so in the case of Sethares/Terhardt style dissonance theory, which considers only unwrapped harmonics.)
Dmitri Tymoczko's Geometrical Methods in Recent Music Theory
Henjan Honing's Musical Cognition: any good?
“Spectral roughness” Dissonance
A particular empirically-motivated metric, with good predictive performance despite its simplicity, and wilful lack of concern for the actual mechanisms of the ear and the brain, or modern nuances such as masking effects and the influence of duration on sound perception etc. Invented by Plomp and Levelt (PlLe65), and developed by variously, Sethares, Terhardt and Parncutt and others.
Some sources seem to distinguish roughness in the sense of Sethares from the Plomp and Levelt sense, although they use qualitatively equations. I suspect therefore that the distinction is philosophical, or possibly pointed failure to cite one another because someone said something rude at the after-conference drinkies.
An overview by Vassilakis might help, or the app based on his work by Dr Kelly Fitz.
Plomp and Levelt's dissonance curves (PlLe65, Seth97).
Juan Sebastian Lach Lau's produced some actual open-source software (DissonanceLib) that attempts to action this stuff in a musical setting. There is a slightly different version below attributed to Parncutt.
A convenient summary of both is in the DissonanceLib code.
It's most useful for things where you are given the harmonics a priori; I'm not especially convinced about the tenability of directly inferring this metric from an audio signal (“how dissonant is this signal?”). We should be cautious about the identifiability of this statistic from signals nonparametrically e.g. windowed DTFT power-spectrogram peaks, just because beat frequency stuff is complicated and runs into the uncertainty principle. Lach11, Seth98b and TeSS82 give it a go, though. Inferring dissonance between two signals known to be not dissonant might work though, or perhaps on might need parametric approaches, as in linear system identification
Dissonance an interesting measure, despite these problems, though because it is very much like a Mercer kernel, in that it constructs a distance defined on an (explicit) high-dimensional space; Also, the “nearly circular” geometry it induces is interesting; For harmonic spectra, you recover the equal-tempered 12-tone scale and the 2:1 octave by minimising dissonance between twelve notes with harmonic spectra (i.e. plucked string spectra), which is suggestive that it might do other useful things.
Also, it's almost-everywhere differentiable with respect to your signal parameters, which makes fitting it or optimising its value easy.
David E Verotta's thoughfully illustrated an essay on this.
Plomp and Levelt's dissonance curves
Attributed to Plomp and Levelt's (PlLe65), here is Sethares' version (Seth98a), also summarised on Sethares' web page.
Dissonance between two pure sinusoidal frequencies, , with amplitudes respectively , is given by:
and , the constants being fit by least-squares from experimental data.
If your note has more than one frequency, one sums the pairwise dissonances of all contributing frequencies to find the total dissonance, which is not biologically plausible but seems to work ok. Other ways of working out differences between two composite sounds could be possible (Hausdorff metric etc).
This looks to me like the kind of situation where the actual details of the curve are not so important as getting the points of maximal and minimal dissonance right. Clearly we have a minimal value at . We solve for the maximally dissonant frequency with respect to a fixed :
That affine difference is reminiscent of resolvability criteria in functional bases.
Parncutt and Barlow dissonance
Differences of exponentials are computationally tedious because of numerical concerns with large frequency values; this is suggestive of approximation by something more convenient, maybe of this form:
The Parncutt approximation takes this approach and additionally transforms the units into heuristically preferable psychoacoustic ones.
Cribbed from Lach Lau's source code and thesis (Lach12), where he attributes it to Parncutt and Barlow, although I can't find any actual articles by Parncutt and/or Barlow which use this. Mash06 implies it might be unpublished. Hans14 gives a squared version of the same formula.
For this we take frequencies and volumes in, respectively, barks and sones. Then
Since this scale is relative, I'm not quite sure why we have constants everywhere.
Possibly in order to more closely approximate Sethares?
TBD. Nestke (2004) and Mazzola (2012). Tymozcko.
- Tous04: Godfried T. Toussaint (2004) A Comparison of Rhythmic Similarity Measures. In ISMIR.
- ReYE12: K. Reese, R. Yampolskiy, A. Elmaghraby (2012) A framework for interactive generation of music for games. In 2012 17th International Conference on Computer Games (CGAMES) (pp. 131–137). Washington, DC, USA: IEEE Computer Society DOI
- Tymo11a: Dmitri Tymoczko (2011a) A Geometry of Music: Harmony and Counterpoint in the Extended Common Practice. New York: Oxford University Press
- XiQi06: Jack Xin, Yingyong Qi (2006) A Many to One Discrete Auditory Transform. ArXiv:Math/0603174.
- Parn97: Richard Parncutt (1997) A model of the perceptual root(s) of a chord accounting for voicing and prevailing tonality. In Music, Gestalt, and Computing (pp. 181–199). Springer Berlin Heidelberg
- CoFa84: Joel Cooper, Russell H. Fazio (1984) A new look at dissonance. Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, 17, 229–268.
- Parn94: Richard Parncutt (1994) A Perceptual Model of Pulse Salience and Metrical Accent in Musical Rhythms. Music Perception: An Interdisciplinary Journal, 11(4), 409–464. DOI
- ReBr69: H. Reitboeck, T. P. Brody (1969) A transformation with invariance under cyclic permutation for applications in pattern recognition. Information and Control, 15(2), 130–154. DOI
- TeSS82: Ernst Terhardt, Gerhard Stoll, Manfred Seewann (1982) Algorithm for extraction of pitch and pitch salience from complex tonal signals. The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 71(3), 679–688. DOI
- HuPa93: David Huron, Richard Parncutt (1993) An improved model of tonality perception incorporating pitch salience and echoic memory. Psychomusicology: A Journal of Research in Music Cognition, 12(2), 154–171. DOI
- CaRS08: M. Casey, C. Rhodes, M. Slaney (2008) Analysis of Minimum Distances in High-Dimensional Musical Spaces. IEEE Transactions on Audio, Speech, and Language Processing, 16(5), 1015–1028. DOI
- HaKD13: S. Hawe, M. Kleinsteuber, K. Diepold (2013) Analysis operator learning and its application to image reconstruction. IEEE Transactions on Image Processing, 22(6), 2138–2150. DOI
- McEl11: Brian McFee, Daniel PW Ellis (2011) Analyzing song structure with spectral clustering. In IEEE conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition (CVPR).
- PaSt94: Richard Parncutt, Hans Strasburger (1994) Applying Psychoacoustics in Composition: “Harmonic” Progressions of “Nonharmonic” Sonorities. Perspectives of New Music, 32(2), 88–129. DOI
- NoFa88: Jan Nordmark, Lennart E. Fahlen (1988) Beat theories of musical consonance. Speech Transmission Laboratory, Quarterly Progress and Status Report.
- BiGS11: Louis Bigo, Jean-Louis Giavitto, Antoine Spicher (2011) Building Topological Spaces for Musical Objects. In Proceedings of the Third International Conference on Mathematics and Computation in Music (pp. 13–28). Berlin, Heidelberg: Springer-Verlag DOI
- Mash06: Keith Mashinter (2006) Calculating sensory dissonance: Some discrepancies arising from the models of Kameoka & Kuriyagawa, and Hutchinson & Knopoff.
- Lerd96: Fred Lerdahl (1996) Calculating tonal tension. Music Perception: An Interdisciplinary Journal, 13(3), 319–363. DOI
- MaQW16: Sephora Madjiheurem, Lizhen Qu, Christian Walder (2016) Chord2Vec: Learning Musical Chord Embeddings.
- Parn06: Richard Parncutt (2006) Commentary on Keith Mashinter’s “Calculating Sensory Dissonance: Some Discrepancies Arising from the Models of Kameoka & Kuriyagawa, and Hutchinson & Knopoff.”
- Kusw11: Heru Kuswanto (2011) Comparison Study of Saron Ricik Instruments’ Sound Color (Timbre) on the Gamelans of Nagawilaga and Gunturmadu from. International Journal of Basic & Applied Sciences.
- CoLL09: Alfonso del Corral, Teresa León, Vicente Liern (2009) Compatibility of the Different Tuning Systems in an Orchestra. In Mathematics and Computation in Music (pp. 93–103). Springer Berlin Heidelberg
- FePa04: Sean Ferguson, Richard Parncutt (2004) Composing In the Flesh: Perceptually-Informed Harmonic Syntax. In Proceedings of Sound and Music Computing.
- PaHa11: Richard Parncutt, Graham Hair (2011) Consonance and dissonance in music theory and psychology: disentangling dissonant dichotomies. J. Interdiscipl. Music Stud, 5, 119–166.
- KaKu69a: Akio Kameoka, Mamoru Kuriyagawa (1969a) Consonance theory part I: Consonance of dyads. The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 45(6), 1451–1459. DOI
- KaKu69b: Akio Kameoka, Mamoru Kuriyagawa (1969b) Consonance theory part II: Consonance of complex tones and its calculation method. The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 45(6), 1460–1469. DOI
- Seth98a: William A. Sethares (1998a) Consonance-Based Spectral Mappings. Computer Music Journal, 22(1), 56. DOI
- Park04: C. G. Chul Gyu Park (2004) Construction of random vectors of heterogeneous component variables under specified correlation structures. Computational Statistics & Data Analysis, 46(4), 621–630. DOI
- CVGL08: M.A. Casey, R. Veltkamp, M. Goto, M. Leman, C. Rhodes, M. Slaney (2008) Content-Based Music Information Retrieval: Current Directions and Future Challenges. Proceedings of the IEEE, 96(4), 668–696. DOI
- Haus99: David Haussler (1999) Convolution kernels on discrete structures. Technical report, UC Santa Cruz
- Wagh76: M.D. Wagh (1976) Cyclic autocorrelation as a translation invariant transform. India, IEE-IERE Proceedings, 14(5), 185–191. DOI
- PeSa09: Salim Perchy, G. Sarria (2009) Dissonances: Brief description and its computational representation in the RTCC calculus. In Proc. of SMC2009, Porto, Portugal.
- ZhSi13: Zhizhen Zhao, Amit Singer (2013) Fourier–Bessel rotational invariant eigenimages. Journal of the Optical Society of America A, 30(5), 871. DOI
- Duff48: R. J. Duffin (1948) Function classes invariant under the Fourier transform. Duke Mathematical Journal, 15(3), 781–785. DOI
- CaQT08: Clifton Callender, Ian Quinn, Dmitri Tymoczko (2008) Generalized voice-leading spaces. Science (New York, N.Y.), 320(5874), 346–348. DOI
- Tymo09a: Dmitri Tymoczko (2009a) Generalizing Musical Intervals. Journal of Music Theory, 53(2), 227–254. DOI
- MBET09: Jakob H. Macke, Philipp Berens, Alexander S. Ecker, Andreas S. Tolias, Matthias Bethge (2009) Generating spike trains with specified correlation coefficients. Neural Computation, 21(2), 397–423. DOI
- Hall08: Rachel Wells Hall (2008) Geometrical Music Theory. Science, 320(5874), 328–329. DOI
- Tymo13: Dmitri Tymoczko (2013) Geometry and the quest for theoretical generality. Journal of Mathematics and Music, 7(2), 127–144. DOI
- Parn89: Richard Parncutt (1989) Harmony: a psychoacoustical approach. Berlin ; New York: Springer-Verlag
- Stol13: Frieder Stolzenburg (2013) Harmony Perception by Periodicity Detection. ArXiv:1306.6458 [Cs].
- TiBB00: Barbara Tillmann, Jamshed J. Bharucha, Emmanuel Bigand (2000) Implicit learning of tonality: a self-organizing approach. Psychological Review, 107(4), 885.
- Shiv11: Vighnesh Leonardo Shiv (2011) Improved frequency estimation in sinusoidal models through iterative linear programming schemes. In Sound and Music Computing Conference, Proceedings.
- DuKL06: Pan Du, Warren A. Kibbe, Simon M. Lin (2006) Improved peak detection in mass spectrum by incorporating continuous wavelet transform-based pattern matching. Bioinformatics, 22(17), 2059–2065. DOI
- HoBo11: Aline Honingh, Rens Bod (2011) In Search of Universal Properties of Musical Scales. Journal of New Music Research, 40(1), 81–89. DOI
- Huro94: David Huron (1994) Interval-Class Content in Equally Tempered Pitch-Class Sets: Common Scales Exhibit Optimum Tonal Consonance. Music Perception: An Interdisciplinary Journal, 11(3), 289–305. DOI
- Reut97: Christoph Reuter (1997) Karl Erich Schumann’s principles of timbre as a helpful tool in stream segregation research. In Music, Gestalt, and Computing (pp. 362–374). Springer Berlin Heidelberg
- MoSF13: Karim Abou- Moustafa, Dale Schuurmans, Frank Ferrie (2013) Learning a Metric Space for Neighbourhood Topology Estimation: Application to Manifold Learning. In Journal of Machine Learning Research (pp. 341–356).
- CaSo03: Ramon Ferrer i Cancho, Ricard V. Solé (2003) Least effort and the origins of scaling in human language. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 100(3), 788–791. DOI
- Tous05: Godfried Toussaint (2005) Mathematical Features for Recognizing Preference in Sub-saharan African Traditional Rhythm Timelines. In Pattern Recognition and Data Mining (Vol. 3686, pp. 18–27). Berlin, Heidelberg: Springer Berlin Heidelberg
- Tymo11b: Dmitri Tymoczko (2011b) Mazzola’s Counterpoint Theory. Mathematics and Computation in Music, Springer, 297–310.
- Herm88: Dik J. Hermes (1988) Measurement of pitch by subharmonic summation. The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 83(1), 257–264. DOI
- SCBH12: Joan Serrà, Álvaro Corral, Marián Boguñá, Martín Haro, Josep Ll Arcos (2012) Measuring the Evolution of Contemporary Western Popular Music. Scientific Reports, 2. DOI
- Bod02: Rens Bod (2002) Memory-based models of melodic analysis: Challenging the Gestalt principles. Journal of New Music Research, 31(1), 27–36. DOI
- BiGT67: Christopher Bingham, M. Godfrey, John W. Tukey (1967) Modern techniques of power spectrum estimation. Audio and Electroacoustics, IEEE Transactions On, 15(2), 56–66.
- Lema97: Marc Leman (1997) Music, Gestalt, and computing: studies in cognitive and systematic musicology (Vol. 1317). Springer
- DeKa07: Ryan J. Demopoulos, Michael J. Katchabaw (2007) Music Information Retrieval: A Survey of Issues and Approaches. Technical Report
- LeCM12: Daniel J. Levitin, Parag Chordia, Vinod Menon (2012) Musical rhythm spectra from Bach to Joplin obey a 1/f power law. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 109(10), 3716–3720. DOI
- FéBD08: Cédric Févotte, Nancy Bertin, Jean-Louis Durrieu (2008) Nonnegative Matrix Factorization with the Itakura-Saito Divergence: With Application to Music Analysis. Neural Computation, 21(3), 793–830. DOI
- BaMe55: M. S. Bartlett, J. Medhi (1955) On the Efficiency of Procedures for Smoothing Periodograms from Time Series with Continuous Spectra. Biometrika, 42(1/2), 143. DOI
- SFGS12: Bharath K. Sriperumbudur, Kenji Fukumizu, Arthur Gretton, Bernhard Schölkopf, Gert R. G. Lanckriet (2012) On the empirical estimation of integral probability metrics. Electronic Journal of Statistics, 6, 1550–1599. DOI
- FFCE16: Rémi Flamary, Cédric Févotte, Nicolas Courty, Valentin Emiya (2016) Optimal spectral transportation with application to music transcription. In arXiv:1609.09799 [cs, stat] (pp. 703–711). Curran Associates, Inc.
- Toiv97: Petri Toiviainen (1997) Optimizing self-organizing timbre maps: Two approaches. In Music, Gestalt, and Computing (pp. 335–350). Springer Berlin Heidelberg
- BoRo90: Paul T. Boggs, Janet E. Rogers (1990) Orthogonal distance regression. Contemporary Mathematics, 112, 183–194.
- BiPa99: Emmanuel Bigand, Richard Parncutt (1999) Perceiving musical tension in long chord sequences. Psychological Research, 62(4), 237–254.
- BiPL96: Emmanuel Bigand, Richard Parncutt, Fred Lerdahl (1996) Perception of musical tension in short chord sequences: The influence of harmonic function, sensory dissonance, horizontal motion, and musical training. Perception & Psychophysics, 58(1), 125–141. DOI
- ThPa97: William Forde Thompson, Richard Parncutt (1997) Perceptual judgments of triads and dyads: Assessment of a psychoacoustic model. Music Perception, 263–280.
- Terh74: Ernst Terhardt (1974) Pitch, consonance, and harmony. The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 55(5), 1061–1069. DOI
- Chev05: Alain de Cheveigné (2005) Pitch Perception Models. In Pitch (pp. 169–233). Springer New York DOI
- RZWS15: Martin Rohrmeier, Willem Zuidema, Geraint A. Wiggins, Constance Scharff (2015) Principles of structure building in music, language and animal song. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological Sciences, 370(1664), 20140097. DOI
- VaKe10: Pantelis N. Vassilakis, Roger A. Kendall (2010) Psychoacoustic and cognitive aspects of auditory roughness: definitions, models, and applications. In IS&T/SPIE Electronic Imaging (pp. 75270O–75270O). International Society for Optics and Photonics
- Parn13: Richard Parncutt (2013) Psychoacoustics and cognition for musicians. Sound Musicianship: Understanding the Crafts of Music, 2.
- Parn05: Richard Parncutt (2005) Psychoacoustics and music perception. Musikpsychologie–Das Neue Handbuch.
- JeRI10: Michael O. Jewell, Christophe Rhodes, Mark d’Inverno (2010) Querying improvised music: Do you sound like yourself? In ISMIR (pp. 483–488). International Society for Music Information Retrieval
- SWMS99: Alex J. Smola, Robert C. Williamson, Sebastian Mika, Bernhard Schölkopf (1999) Regularized Principal Manifolds. In Computational Learning Theory (pp. 214–229). Springer Berlin Heidelberg
- HeVo13: J. Leo van Hemmen, Andreas N. Vollmayr (2013) Resonating vector strength: what happens when we vary the “probing” frequency while keeping the spike times fixed. Biological Cybernetics, 107(4), 491–494. DOI
- Krum00: Carol L. Krumhansl (2000) Rhythm and pitch in music cognition. Psychological Bulletin, 126(1), 159. DOI
- GaMa12: Mike Gashler, Tony Martinez (2012) Robust manifold learning with CycleCut. Connection Science, 24(1), 57–69. DOI
- KSPC12: Heru Kuswanto, Sumarna, Agus Purwanto, Cipto Budy Handoyo (2012) Saron demung instruments timbre spectrum comparison study on the gamelans sekati from Karaton Ngayogyakarta. International Journal of Basic & Applied Sciences.
- Kusw12: H. Kuswanto (2012) Saron demung’s timbre and sonogram of gamelans gunturmadu from Keraton Ngayogyakarta. Jurnal Pendidikan Fisika Indonesia, 8(1).
- Mazz12: Guerino Mazzola (2012) Singular homology on hypergestures. Journal of Mathematics and Music, 6(1), 49–60. DOI
- Hans14: Brian Hansen (2014) Spatial Utilization of Sensory Dissonance and the Creation of Sonic Sculpture. . Ann Arbor, MI: Michigan Publishing, University of Michigan Library
- Seth97: William A. Sethares (1997) Specifying spectra for musical scales. The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 102(4), 2422–2431. DOI
- SMTP09: William A. Sethares, Andrew J. Milne, Stefan Tiedje, Anthony Prechtl, James Plamondon (2009) Spectral Tools for Dynamic Tonality and Audio Morphing. Computer Music Journal, 33(2), 71–84. DOI
- GaMa11: Mike Gashler, Tony Martinez (2011) Tangent space guided intelligent neighbor finding. (pp. 2617–2624). IEEE DOI
- CoMP12: Marion Cousineau, Josh H. McDermott, Isabelle Peretz (2012) The basis of musical consonance as revealed by congenital amusia. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 109(48), 19858–19863. DOI
- DGMR05: Erik D. Demaine, Francisco Gomez-Martin, Henk Meijer, David Rappaport, Perouz Taslakian, Godfried T. Toussaint, … David R. Wood (2005) The Distance Geometry of Deep Rhythms and Scales. In CCCG (pp. 163–166).
- DGMR09: Erik D. Demaine, Francisco Gomez-Martin, Henk Meijer, David Rappaport, Perouz Taslakian, Godfried T. Toussaint, … David R. Wood (2009) The distance geometry of music. In Computational Geometry (Vol. 42, pp. 429–454). DOI
- Li06: Guangming Li (2006) The effect of inharmonic and harmonic spectra in Javanese gamelan tuning (1): a theory of the sléndro. In Proceedings of the 7th WSEAS International Conference on Acoustics & Music: Theory & Applications (pp. 65–71). World Scientific and Engineering Academy and Society (WSEAS)
- Tymo12: Dmitri Tymoczko (2012) The Generalized Tonnetz. Journal of Music Theory, 56(1), 1–52. DOI
- Tymo06: Dmitri Tymoczko (2006) The Geometry of Musical Chords. Science, 313(5783), 72–74. DOI
- RaPl99: Rudolf Rasch, Reinier Plomp (1999) The perception of musical tones. The Psychology of Music, 2, 89–112.
- StVo40: S. S. Stevens, J. Volkmann (1940) The relation of pitch to frequency: a revised scale. The American Journal of Psychology, 53(3), 329–353. DOI
- Tymo09b: Dmitri Tymoczko (2009b) Three Conceptions of Musical Distance. In Mathematics and Computation in Music (pp. 258–272). Springer Berlin Heidelberg DOI
- PlLe65: Reinier Plomp, Willem JM Levelt (1965) Tonal consonance and critical bandwidth. The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 38(4), 548–560. DOI
- Lerd88: Fred Lerdahl (1988) Tonal Pitch Space. Music Perception: An Interdisciplinary Journal, 5(3), 315–349. DOI
- BuSe14: Ryan Budney, William Sethares (2014) Topology of Musical Data. Journal of Mathematics and Music, 8(1), 73–92. DOI
- Carl87: Wendy Carlos (1987) Tuning: At the Crossroads. Computer Music Journal, 11(1), 29–43. DOI
- Seth98b: William A. Sethares (1998b) Tuning, Timbre, Spectrum, Scale. Springer London
- BaLo87: Clarence Barlow, Henning Lohner (1987) Two Essays on Theory. Computer Music Journal, 11(1), 44. DOI
- NiJa01: F. Nicolls, G. de Jager (2001) Uniformly most powerful cyclic permutation invariant detection for discrete-time signals. (Vol. 5, pp. 3165–3168). IEEE DOI
- Fokk69: Adriaan Daniel Fokker (1969) Unison vectors and periodicity blocks in 3-dimensional (3-5-7-) harmonic lattice of notes. Proceedings of the Koninklijke Nederlandse Akademie van Wetenschappen Series B-Physical Sciences, 72(3), 153.
- CoFK07: Norman D. Cook, Takashi X. Fujisawa, Hiroo Konaka (2007) Why Not Study Polytonal Psychophysics? Empirical Musicology Review, 2(1).
- Zane06: Damiáan H. Zanette (2006) Zipf’s law and the creation of musical context. Musicae Scientiae, 10(1), 3–18. DOI